Boomerang Pizza Kitchen - Milton

Man I wanted to give 4 stars but just couldn't do it. Let me go over pros first. I brought my daughter for a daddy daughter date night and we genuinely enjoyed ourselves. The pizza did have good flavor and the wait staff was prompt and courteous. The atmosphere is whimsical but more on that in a moment. Now the cons, while the pizza had good flavor I could have taken a bath in the grease pool that was on top of it. The sauce was wildly delicious and it was a shame it was washed put by such a heavy layer of grease. The atmosphere is whimsical but the decor could use some updates. While it is overall clean it felt like a back alley restaurant instead of a quaint downtown restaurant like I would expect given where it sits. The front shop is great and our overall experience was good but I couldn't bring myself to give 4 stars simply because of some easy fixes they could make to enhance the experience.

We are new to Milton and wanted to try a new pizza place instead of eating one of the chain pizza places. Boomerang Pizza was good and when I went in to pick up the pizza I saw what a neat place the restaurant is as well. We will definitely go back to dine in sometime so my family can see everything the general store has. It's very neat and I would love to try some of the fudge!

We usually order here on Fridays, great pizza, they sell yummy chocolate inside and they have dining room also

This place is amazing!! It not only has a retro look, but before you get to the pizza you walk through a store full of retro toys, games, candy and displays. Their is a counter full of fudge, cookies, candies, cakes all made right there in shop. They also have a little corner of merchandise from the locals (the candles smell good enough to eat) they you get to hostess stand with a super cute little waiting area for the kids with retro toys to play with...... The food is SO good we got a cheese pizza, their buffalo dough-knots and a calzone. The dough is made in house (you can watch from the front window) the flavors were vibrant and the service was friendly and all around great!! The kids thought it was amazing!!

Love this place, I wish I lived closer. Cute place and service was great. Thanks for the delicious pizza and accommodating our large group.