Cataro's Italian Villa - Milwaukee

Small place but nice italian food is being cooked. Also, not to mention, name one place that can make a scratch made meat sauce... I'll wait... Cataros italian Villa is definitely one place in West Allis you have to eat at if you are feeling italian food. Reasonable sized portions, and definitely one place where you can strike up conversations but also be bringing home some leftovers for later. Great taste and lots more to come.

Ballesteries isn't much further away for pickup, but we love Cataro's pizza!

Crust was okay and service was fast but the pizza was tasteless and had about a pinch of sauce.. was eating cheesebread basically. Walk in looked very dirty. Glance at the kitchen look disgusting

We had a group of 14 and they were very accomodating. Pizza and garlic bread were Great as always.

It was fine, but, no one checked on our table after serving until checque was dropped off. And they only take cash. Good thing I'm one of the last 5 people on earth that carry cash. Wheelchair accessibility: Yes