Grey Lady - Montauk

I might have given this place 4 stars had I come on a Friday or Saturday night, however was here on a Sunday after the weekend crowd had left town and it

I'd have less splinters and more drinks if the service was commensurate with the $$$. Food was solid, but why am I coming to the grey lady for lobster rolls?

Having been to Happy Hour at Grey Lady on Delancey Street, we were glad to see they opened an outpost in Montauk, where Happy Hour $1.00 oysters are hard to

This restaurant is closed. Open Table must be removed from the list.

Turned up on our reservation to find the restaurant was closed. Regular meal time Our reservation was made for days in advance ....