Kenny's Castaways - MONTAUK

In town for 5 nights, and came here twice. Dinner was excellent both times. Below is my espresso encrusted yellow fin tuna. Try the zeppole for desert!!! Staff is attentive, friendly and always helpful.

The worst over cooked, microwaved slop!! Was told it was cooked to order?food came out in 3 minutes!!! Who is fooled by this?? Mario, the owner is an unpleasant person to deal with. It was high season on a Thursday evening and the place was empty!! The waitress wore open toed sandals, unsanitary at best. 2 plates I?d awful flood Nd one glass of s so wine?.97 dollars prior to tip!!! I should have walked away , my bad. DO NOT GO, EVEN IF YOU ARE STARVING!!!!

Best dining experience ever. Mario and staff amazing. The lasagna ????was delicious. The place is warm and inviting. The treatment we received was the mark of a true professional restaurant. Thank you Mario we will be back. Any negative reviews don't believe them. We recommended your place to 10 people back at our hotel.

We ordered the chicken Caesar salad, 4 orders of the Penne Vodka, 3 orders of the chicken parmigiana, and the inferno pizza. The food was so delicious that everyone finished everything on their plate which can be rare in our family. The owner Mario was incredibly personable and his staff was extraordinary. The food was brought to the table quickly and the ambience of the restaurant was cozy and welcoming. We were very happy with our decision to dine at Kenny?s Castaway and we will be returning in the future. Thank you again to Mario for an excellent dinner!

Our party of eight had dinner this evening at Kenny?s Castaways. The authentic Italian food and pizza were delicious and enjoyed by everyone. Mario and his staff was most accommodating to our requests. We recommend this warm and cozy restaurant to anyone that loves Italian food. Buon Appetite!