Colgate Inn Tap Room - New York

Kali was attentive, prompt, and very friendly. Great waitress and much appreciated. Rooms: 5 Service: 5 Location: 5 Hotel highlights: Romantic

In town visiting from Arizona and had a fabulous meal with great service by Zoey! The menu was creative and the food well-prepared.

Five of us dined here on a Sunday evening. We got here about a half hour before our reservation time they were happy to seat us serve us drinks. The bartender and also the waitress Zoey were extremely personable and very welcoming. We had the fried pickles as an appetizer they were good! Three pasta dishes that were ordered were excellent, as was the fish barramundi Caesar salad. The chocolate cake cake that was shared was delicious!

This place speaks for itself. Old time Luxury hotel nicely kept. people at the front desk. Could not have been nicer, great atmoyou're. Rooms: 5 Service: 4 Location: 5

We recently had a group of almost 50 stay at the Colgate Inn for a family reunion. The accommodations were lovely and the service from every single employee was outstanding. We are still talking about the great hamburgers that we had our first evening eating on the terrace outside the grill room. Hamilton and the Inn made a wonderful venue for our group. We had family members from all over the country. We were a bit nervous having made the recommendation to our group to try the Inn after years of gathering in Vermont. It couldn't have been better and we thank you for doing such a great job.