Lillie's Victorian Establishment

We stopped in for brunch before seeing a show. We absolutely loved the holiday decor and the food! The service was just okay, it took a long time to get anything, and after asking for the check it took close to 15 minutes for the server to return. The table next to us ordered eggs which still hadn't come out 30 mins after receiving the rest of their order.

The first thing that will amaze you is the restaurant's Decor especially at Christmas time (when we went You'll need to reserve the table in advance, though walks in are welcome (like we did but we waited around 90 mins to get the table reserved for 1;30 PM...The host helped accommodate us... we got the corner table and waited around 10 minutes for the server to take our order. I don't mind (not a tourist, from Jersey so I understand the culture or I am more understanding, you can say ; til then we enjoyed sitting on a cozy sofa enjoying the decor! We ordered Shrimp Scampi wifey did not like it, as per her feedback spaghetti was not boiled properly. she asked for Parmesn to season it. thing is we Indians don't believe in wasting food, if she had complained, they would have thrown out the food which is not acceptable to us anyway, we gave the feedback to the server 2.5/5 Chicken Salad Sandwich Mashed chicken with Pesto, arugula, and Fries it was good, I liked it 4/5 I Know New York is a touristy place, but restaurants with a history like this, make New York what it is. Price Reasonable no burden on your pocket Service It could be improved, but given the holiday season and how mad rush it is out there, it's fine for me at least Decor Christmas Decor is amazing, extra star for Decor.

Really cool place. I had a taste of the 'Fly me to the Moon ' and wow! If I drank alcohol I would get this every time.

I purchased 2 premium tickets for NYE which were advertised as buffet and open bar from 8pm-4am. When we arrived, we were told there was no buffet (only choice of 1 app, entree, side and dessert) with open bar until midnight only. This was very disappointing and no explanation was offered, except that whoever wrote the initial post did not communicate with the kitchen. Decor was amazing and food wasn’t bad, but this miscommunication and false advertising was very disappointing. Especially given the high price of the tickets. I had questions prior to the event and tried to call (straight to voicemail), email and DM but did not receive a response. In this case, I think the only course of action would be a partial refund as we did not receive what was advertised.

Stopped in for a cocktail but this location didn’t have the liquor required for what we wanted so we settled for a glass of wine. Staff was very friendly. The atmosphere was fun.