Brooklyn Pizza - Newburgh

My wife and I are originally from New York but now live in Pennsylvania. We really miss New York pizza! While we were in town for my daughter's wedding, we realized we hadn't had any pizza yet before heading back home. That's when we discovered Brooklyn Pizza and decided to give it a try. The garlic knots were excellent, and we ordered a large pizza to enjoy on our way. Thank you for helping us relive our fond memories of the pizza we miss so much. We'll definitely be back!

I have no complaints about the food at Brooklyn Pizza, especially my favorite item, the exclusive “Buffalo Knots.” They are truly addictive! Danny comes from a long line of pizza makers and works tirelessly to maintain the traditional recipes and family sauce. He treats everyone like family and goes above and beyond for the community. He’s the kind of person who would give you the shirt off his back, and because of that, he definitely has my support—not only for that reason but also for the amazing, honest, local pizza! It’s a must-visit spot, especially for those in Buffalo. If you haven’t tried it yet, you’re really missing out, I promise!

I stopped by on a whim and I wasn't disappointed! I ordered a couple of plain slices, and they were outstanding! The crust was thin and perfectly cooked, the sauce was flavorful, and there was just the right amount of cheese. I will definitely be back!

My mother-in-law says this is the closest to the pizza she had in the city growing up. Also good dinners. Recommend the lasagna.