Goodfellas Pizzeria Inc - Niagara Falls

What a surprise! That was the outcome of our dining experience. The building's exterior, with its high security on the doors, initially made us question whether we should enter. However, we decided to go in and found the interior to be old but charming. Although there were no draft taps, our server was kind and attentive. As we sat down, we continued to be curious about the place. We noticed a steady flow of pickup orders and observed many customers addressing the staff by their first names. When our wings arrived, they were fantastic and definitely worth the wait.

The pizza at this restaurant is excellent! My husband ordered a pepperoni slice, while I opted for a white pizza made to order. Both were delicious and our server provided great service.

I recently had the worst pizza and wings of my life at this restaurant. After calling to complain, the woman on the phone was great and offered a full refund if I returned the food. I decided to keep the drinks and everything seemed fine. The restaurant closed at 11 pm, and when a man arrived to collect the food, he was not the original delivery driver but the owner of the restaurant. He asked to come into my hotel room for a minute, which I declined. He then deducted the cost of the drinks from my bill. It was disappointing to see the owner in such a drunken state, and the quality of the food was terrible – the pizza looked like it had been mangled and the wings were dry. Overall, a very pathetic experience.

The place overall could use a little fixing up. But we were there for the food. And may I say it was dang good! Miss Keri awesome! Great service! Very friendly! The pizza was really good. The cheese they use was freaking great! Their cheese steaksare also among the best I've ever had.

Visiting from IL and was told this was the best pizza in town and it was awesome. Best pizza and wings!