May Kelly's Cottage - North Conway

My wife and I ate here at our third night in the area and we wish it had been our first! The flesh of Mary was amazing and my wife had the shepherds with lamb... We just wish we had tried all the other items on the menu.

Delicious! Here came two nights in a row because it was easy, in great ambience, reasonable prices and above all good food.

The decor is eclectic. Kelly green and bright red color and stuff, tons of stuff everywhere and the lighting is dim. The food was delicious. Tried the app special, large juicy scallops wrapped in good smokey bacon and a contrasting mustard dresses over fresh mesculine greens. Yum! Shepherd cake was traditional and delicious. Caesar Salat was very lightly dressed with homemade dressing and I had steak tips that were just ok. very friendly staff. A fun place to go, but not if you are a wine drinker.

Great food and great service. My son said the corned beef and cabbage was A+. Shepards pie was delicious. Nice atmosphere and lots to look at. Will go back for sure.

YUM!!. My husband and I make it up to North Conway a few times a year, and we ALWAYS reserve a meal for May Kelly's. The corned beef is so soft, not fatty, and just melts in your mouth. Clam Chowder is perfectly creamy with tons of flavor. I'll be there in just a few weeks and I can't wait!