Mario's Pizzeria Of Oyster Bay

The food was incredible, but be warned... the portions are HUGE! You're definitely getting your money's worth here! I will definitely be ordering again!

The food here is amazing! I visit frequently, and the staff is fantastic—especially Maxwell, Naomy, Jerry, Kaylah, and Elias (same name)! I would definitely recommend this place!

The pizza was good, but I ordered fresh garlic and received a lot of onions instead, which was not quite the same. Overall, it was still enjoyable.

Fantastic pizza with a wonderful staff! I always enjoy grabbing a fresh plain slice to eat on-site. They cut their extra-large pies into six generous slices, and everything is always fresh. The buffalo chicken pizza is outstanding!

About a month ago, I ordered a chicken parm hero, and it was terrible—dry, with not enough sauce or cheese, and the bread was soggy alongside the dry chicken. A few weeks back, I tried their Sicilian pie with sausage, and it was just as bad. The dough was raw, and the unseasoned sauce tasted like plain crushed tomatoes from a can, lacking any oregano or other spices. There was also very little cheese and sausage. When I called to complain, their response was, “Sorry to hear that, but I bet you ate it all.” Today, I had two slices from the counter and they were great, as always. My recommendation is to stick to the regular Neapolitan slice and look elsewhere for good Italian food. It’s sad to see how far they’ve fallen. UPDATE: Fast forward to August 2024, and it’s only getting worse! I ordered chicken Parmesan with linguine and marinara sauce, which was al dente but a bit too hard and undercooked. The chicken breast was dried out and pounded thin, the sauce tasted sour, and there was just a tiny bit of cheese with mushy, overcooked pasta to top it off. Honestly, it wouldn’t have made a difference—the place seems to be finished. Letting the staff run the show like this is a recipe for disaster, and it feels like they're headed for business failure!