Eli's Old-fashioned Ice Cream Soda

This restaurant is no longer in business. I’m not sure why Yelp and Google still list it as open. The location has shut down, and the phone number provided is disconnected.

This charming old-fashioned ice cream parlor offers a delightful variety of delicious ice cream flavors, friendly service, and reasonable prices—what more could you ask for? They also have a limited selection of lunch items and other treats. Stop by for a tasty delight and a touch of nostalgia!

Eli's Ice Cream is a fantastic place to enjoy some classic ice cream. Located in a repurposed bank on the historic Main Street, it offers a refreshing alternative to the more corporate ice cream shops found throughout Utah.

Quaint, old school ice cream parlor in a historical bank building. Prices are better than chain stores and they serve BYU Creamery Ice Cream (which is tasty and much more convenient than driving to Provolone). Stop by for a sweet treat and enjoy the nostalgic atmosphere.

This spot is a literal time machine! (Ok not literally but you catch my drift) it's an ice cream parlor inside an old bank so while you wait for your ice cream to be scooped you can explore. Located on Payson main street, this place is a must! They serve Aggie creamery ice cream and it is delicious! My favorite flavor I have ever had was here at Eli's Graham Canyon, it was out of this world! It was creamy and delicious. I visit this spot every time I go to Payson. Great staff, great pricing, great ice cream!