Anthony's Italian Grill - Pembroke

Absolutely delicious food, great drinks, and a great selection!!! Service was impeccable!! We will definitely be going here again. Was a great family restaurant would also be great for romantic scene. 5 stars

Really enjoyed our experience here! Great food, and very welcoming and excellent service! Very nice ambiance as well! Was the perfect spot for a nice date night!

Nice and quiet, friendly staff, good selection of food. They have a great atmosphere that is quite. They accommodated food sensitivities and special needs very very well. The waitress who served us were so very kind and helpful. All the guests were friendly and talkative. Excellent restaurant I would come back! Parking is available on the street or in the back. It’s a great place to try if you are visiting! It’s clean and comfortable nice place to talk and really take a night off. Slow down and enjoy! ???

An amazing place to bring your better half to a nice date night or have any type of celebration! Food is done with utmost care and everything is delicious!

Let’s start with the positives: the Caesar salad was quite delicious and enjoyable, topped with tasty homemade croutons. It really built my anticipation for the entrée, which unfortunately took 30 to 45 minutes to arrive after I finished my salad. I chose the chicken marsala, described as pan-braised chicken supreme with a marsala wine reduction, sautéed mushrooms, garlic mashed potatoes, and seasonal vegetables. However, the chicken seemed baked, overly dry, and unseasoned—definitely overcooked. The mushrooms were not sautéed, and the marsala sauce tasted more like canned tomato paste than a proper Italian sauce. If you compare my photo of the dish to authentic chicken marsala images online, you’ll see this dish bears no resemblance to the classic. The garlic mashed potatoes lacked any garlic flavor, were lumpy, hard, and drier than the Sahara. The vegetables were boiled and utterly flavorless. Although I usually manage to finish bad meals, I couldn’t get through even a quarter of this plate before giving up. I wouldn’t recommend dining here if you’re in the area. After a beer and tip, my bill was over $70, and I ended up going somewhere else for dinner. EDIT (Response to Owner): I didn’t specify May 23rd; I meant May 2023. Just to clarify, it was May 16th, 2023—four months ago, not three, as you mentioned. Your math and your professionalism appear to be as lacking as your food. Interesting.