Wise Guys Pizzeria - Penn Yan

I'm a plumber in new york city and I always try different types of pizza. I started with the good review I read of wise guys pizza and will not be looking any further. This is great pizza compared to NYC standards. I'm always with the plain pie, (always Xtra cheese). When I come back, thats where I'm going! I don't have time to be trying out everything!

While I don't think their Pizza is the best you can get (I make my own), their subs are fantastic! I love the chicken finger sub with BBQ sauce and bleu cheese.

Love their pizzas. Chicken wing pizza is the best! Service is always great with consistent quality.

Excellent pizza. The sauce is excellent and taste like homemade Italian. This place will not disappoint!