Pizzeria New York - Pickerington

Just ordered wings, white pizza and pepperoni pizza. Awesome!

I just wish I would’ve known sooner! My wife and I had the pepperoni rolls and the pin wheels! They were so good I didn’t even get a chance to take picture! Don’t sleep on these two menu items! I’m telling ya! Go try it for yourself! The cheese was melting over. The sauce, kinda of a marinara but a slight spice with a hint of sweet! Dough was finely tuned to a nice slight burnt texture with a crunchy final bite. To top it off, the butter poured over was the glistening touch! Dig in!!!

Has been a while since I sat inside and ate. Although I asked about table service, there really isn't because you have to order at the counter yourself. The atmosphere is rather messey and would not recommend eating inside. The pizza was amazingly good and appreciated that. The pizza was delivered to the table. The staff were friendly and helpful. Pizza is recommended.

Our first time eating here. The pizza was great and looked like a pizza artist put it together lol. It was gorgeous! My only complaint is that we ordered old world pepperoni and a few veggies but there was spicy pepperoni on it also. I dont like spicy but everyone else loved it! I guess it was just a mistake and that certainly will not stop me from going back! The young man who took our order was so friendly and helpful ! Very good pizza !!

One of the better New York style pizzas in pickerington