Pine Island Pizza - Pine Island Center

I would have given more stars had the employee not stacked my pizza slices on top of each other ?

Family owned, new owners Tim and Mandy. Not new to the pizza game. Good food, loved the meatballs.

Love that they have a thinner crust! They recently changed their pepperonis and they're fantastic!! So much more flavor and spice love getting a well done bake to get them extra crispy. This will definitely keep us coming back! Thank you Pine Island Pizza!!

Pretty good Pizza.. better than Dominos that's for sure

If your from Jersey it’s the only pizza place that’ll remind you from back home.