Peter's Pizzeria - Port Saint Joe

Wish I could give you my take on their pizza but I couldn't get them to not place me on hold endlessly! First call I was left on hold for 10 minutes. Second call I was placed on hold long enough that I drove to the location from my motel to find that there wasn't another customer even at the restaurant they instantly ask if they could help me. My response was please take me off hold as I had their hold muzak playing over the speaker on my phone. Sorry but if you don't want to take orders over the phone then don't answer it!

Was really impressed with the pizza here, we ordered a regular pie and Caesar salad, both were huge portions. The crust was done just right and the combination of cheeses was robust and full of flavor. I recommend takeout as the dining area was quite small especially if there is a line. Well worth the wait, I had been craving a good slice and this did not disappoint.

We need several pizzas for a large crowd. They had them fast and the pizzas were great! John helped carry the pizzas to my car. It is a great place to get a slice or a whole pie! We will be back!

We got there late when they were about to close, and grabbed a pizza roll that was left and it was so good. The pizza crust was very tasty and the fresh made marinara was our favorite . You could tell a lot of care and passion went into making everything with good fresh ingredients. We will definitely be back for breakfast soon.

This place was NOT worth the money. the menu online did not match the payment in person. The pizza was mediocre at best but not worth 22 dollars. To get any toppings it was 3 dollars extra to add the LIMITED toppings they offered. The margarita pizza which is just cheese, sauce, and some basil was 25 dollars, INSANE. With that price I should have gotten a actual margarita with it. Overall this place needs a reality check and start matching their prices with their costco brand pizza.