Jay's Incredible Pizza - Porters Neck

OMG! We LOVE Jay's Incredible Pizza! Appearantly there's new management and a new chef (Jay! who have kept the best parts of the menu and improved the service. Hooray! We were drawn in by trying their Chicago style deep dish pizza but then saw so many other unique options that we've been back several more times. Can't believe no one else has come up with Pickle Pizza! Love it! :D

Finally being run by new owners!!. Phone answered quickly and politely. Ingredients fresh and plentiful. The Mediterranean pizza super yummy and, unlike before not chopped into tiny pieces. The large size will feed the two of us for a couple of meals

This is my new go-to pizza place in Wilmington! The wait times on weekends or busy nights can be pretty long, but that's to be expected for quality pizza. All the interactions I've had with the staff have been pleasant and friendly. I haven't ordered anything from here yet that wasn't incredible, it definitely lives up to the name! The pickle pizza is a must try, and the stuffed poppers (with pepperoni! are a must order.

Glad we gave this place a try; it instantly became our go-to for pizza if we are craving it. Great crisp crust, not doughy, good cheese and sauce, and great toppings. It’s noticeable, I’m a weirdo that digs pineapple on pizza and I can tell this places uses fresh pineapple whereas other places use canned pineapple.

Worst pizza in all of Wilmington. You'd expect a lot more considering their prices. Poor ingredients, undercooked. Huge waste of my money!