Jimmy Jims Deli - SAG HARBOR

Caution: While the menu displayed on the board shows that every sandwich is around $10, if you choose anything that's not listed, such as opting for a roll instead of regular bread, you'll be hit with an additional charge of $2.50. This seems excessive and possibly questionable.

Jimmy Jims provides excellent attention to every customer who walks in. They acknowledge your presence right away and ensure you’re attended to without long waiting times.

Incredible sandwiches! The breakfast sandwiches are fantastic, but the tortas truly steal the show. The breaded chicken topped with melted mozzarella, refried beans, lettuce, tomato, and roasted jalapeño on a perfectly crispy bread is simply the best.

I spent $18 on a chicken cutlet sandwich and an iced tea. The food was cooked in stale oil, which left an unappetizing flavor that had a hint of bacon and something else. I wouldn’t recommend this place—I certainly won’t be coming back.

This has become my favorite place for food and drinks. Their wing night is amazing!