Old City House - Saint Augustine

Best restaurant in town!!! Food, service.. even price were outstanding

Such a quaint little restaurant, with the absolute most delicious food ever. I enjoyed a fresh cocktail and old fashion with LaSardo cherries followed by the tuna tartare as an appetizer. I want you to the beef tenderloin. Entrée was delicious. I was very impressed with the way the potatoes were presented. I was dining for a remembrance celebration and the servers were very caring about that at my dining experience.

We live in the town and frequent this restaurant quite often. I usually don't pay much attention to the food and mainly go out for the atmosphere, people-watching, and to spend quality time with my wife, family, or friends. However, I must admit that I am a big fan of the food here. It may not be cheap, but it is reasonably priced considering the quality. We have tried the lamb, filet, and pork multiple times and have always been satisfied. During our last visit, there was Chilean Seabass on the menu, which I absolutely loved and consider it to be the best I've ever had. The staff is excellent – they are knowledgeable, attentive, and very friendly.

I wasn’t sure what to expect after reading several reviews. They were right, when they are off their game the dinning experience is absolutely horrible. Way to hot and muggy inside the restaurant. Why they would subject their fine dining guests to Florida heat is inexcusable. Their game was way off tonight as the chef tried to serve a substandard over cooked piece of “meat” as a tenderloin. By the time the chef corrected the snafu, I was done my pork chop. Completely ruined our last night in this beautiful city. Take your chances at a casino, not this restaurant.

Absolutely adore visiting!!! The food is always fresh and delicious and the staff couldn't be more attentive. Always a great experience.