J B Prestano Bakery - Sayville

There are times when you're all over the country and you're baffled by the lack of rainbow cookies. Then there are those moments when you finally have some, and it's like a lightbulb goes off in your mind because they are so fresh and precisely what you were craving. Sometimes you find yourself writing a review on Google Maps that may seem like an exaggeration—but can it really be considered an exaggeration?

I come here for all my pastry needs, and I absolutely love their coffee! They are truly the best! The coffee-flavored ice cream rivals even the more expensive cafés, and I’m completely smitten with the extra touches they offer. From the tasty baked goods to the delightful ice cream, this place pays attention to every detail, and it really shows. It’s consistently delicious, with super friendly service and charming interior decor. Without a doubt, this is my favorite neighborhood bakery!

I ordered a half naked cake from Dolci Momenti bakery, and I absolutely loved it. We had a small backyard wedding with family, and everyone was thrilled with how the cake turned out. It was filled with vanilla and buttercream, which made it delicious.

One of the best Italian bakeries in the area, its location is easy to reach from 495.