The Old Mill Pizzeria - Sciota

For over twenty years one of our favorite Best Stromboli, Best Greek Salad! Staff all pleasant and the owner Izzi is fantastic

I was really pleasantly surprised by this place, and I had a wonderful slice of Grandma Pizza when I stopped in the area a day after work. Typically, I don't think about Stroudsburg as an area where I can get good quality pizza, but this little place is worth a visit. Do not be parked if there are no other cars in the parking lot. It does not reflect the ZIP code safe food. Typically, I try places where I don't see other diners, but I gave this place a chance, and I'm glad I did. The grandma pie, as I said, was delicious, they supplement small Drizzles from Pesto, a slight variation from most. But I thought it tastes great! The crust was not too thick, slightly crunchy on it, cheese melted up nice, and the sauce was hearty and exactly how to taste Grandma sauce. I could say it was fresh, it wasn't before the day pizza or something. The owners there are very nice, I talked to them for a few minutes. They obviously take care of their customers, and I really respect the product they expose what with the challenges that a business in this area has. Kudos to you! Also the place is super clean and the atmosphere is beautiful. I thought they deserved a scream!

I ordered the shrimp sampling, only at the end of eating two shrimps and within an hour my stomach hurt me and then I started throwing the shrimp sampling. I'm disappointed because I loved this place, but now I won't return. As I feel now, it's not worth coming back and my husband agrees.

Went and ordered a pepperoni pizza for dinner. It was one of the best pizzas that we had in a long time. I definitely would recommend eating at Old Mill Pizza.

5 Stars for their cheese steaks, it's not just a pizza joint they also have gyros. You can get it to go or dine in.