First Slice Pie Cafe - side

The pie is good. The staff is friendly and the other customers seem to enjoy their pies as well.

I pre-ordered and paid for 2 pies for pick up for my husband’s birthday this week. When I went to pick them up, they only had one of them available and said they sold out of the other (not sure why I prepaid). They told me they would refund me asap, but it’s been 4 days and I still have not gotten my refund. I was hesitant to leave this review despite them messing up the birthday plans we had, but the fact that I can’t even get a refund or response from a manager is unbelievable. I love their pi … – show

Go to for dessert. Favorites are peanut butter and key lime.

Such a treat! My first time there. I went for lunch and had the duck confit sandwich with chips and a latte. Sandwich was delicious combination of flavors and the pie was even better!!! Can’t wait to go back.

The pie is amazing. Highly recommend it and it's soup season so we are going to come back. However… it is pretty unhinged to charge $1.25 for substitute milk and last time we went there, the bill said $1.50 for oat milk. So it seems things just fluctuate when this place sees fit. That's higher than anywhere I've seen, for oat milk and i movedfrom LA. So I do not recommend getting any hot bevs from here as it's very egregious pricing. Also regular milk is $5 a gallon. Can you justify charging … – show