La Slice Pizzeria - South Farmingdale

I have to say, the pizza was amazing! The server told me I'd come back, and she was spot on—I absolutely will return. If you weren't aware before, now you are!

I've visited this restaurant several times after finding it online and seeing the positive reviews. The sandwiches are fantastic, and the pizza is also very tasty. They have great weekly specials as well. It's definitely worth a visit!

The pizza here is consistently excellent! This is my favorite place for garlic knots; they've truly mastered the perfect balance of bread, garlic, and oil.

I used to live in this area and recently returned to visit family, so I decided to revisit my favorite pizza place. Unfortunately, the previous owners are no longer there, and it shows in the food quality. The pizza was bland, the sauce tasted like store-bought Ragu, and I had an unpleasant experience when I called to place my pickup order. It's disappointing to see how the new owners have significantly downgraded what was once a fantastic spot.

In my view, La Slice in Farmingdale serves the best Grandma pizza around. Although we live in Oceanside, which boasts many fantastic pizzerias, La Slice stands out as one of the best. If you're in the area or willing to make the drive, it's definitely worth a visit. You won't be disappointed!