Pirates Pizza - South Orange

I stopped by for some pizza and wings and was surprised to see new ownership, so I decided to give it a shot. BIG MISTAKE! The pizza was a complete disappointment; the dough was flavorless, and the sauce was overwhelmingly salty. I had requested a crispy crust, but that didn't come across clearly. Instead, the crust wasn't crispy at all, and to top it off, both slices were placed on top of each other in the same box! The wings were dry and seemed like they had been overcooked or reheated too many times. Needless to say, I won’t be returning to this restaurant.

I always see Kori at this restaurant. She tends to eat the leftover slices I leave behind. Honestly, I don't mind at all because the food is fantastic and the service is excellent!

The pizza was just average, and the onion rings were quite disappointing. Furthermore, their business practices feel a bit underhanded. I ordered a half Veg/plain pizza over the phone, and the person at the counter failed to inform me about additional charges for the veggie toppings, which ended up costing me an extra $10. While I was in the store, I overheard an older customer expressing her confusion about why her sandwich cost $22. There are many other great pizza places nearby; I would recommend steering clear of this one.

I’m kind of upset I took so long to try this spot. Their food is really high quality. Everything always tastes fresh, hot, and delicious. I’ve had them like 4 times now it always hits the spot. Just really good overall.

Honestly, speaking for the first time since the pandemic I can say that the food is decent. Yes, I