O'mallys - Southold

My family and I enjoyed a Sunday lunch at O'Mallys. The steak I had was excellent along with sides of veggies. Good value for the price. Nice atmosphere and staff. We will definitely return on a future visit to the North Fork.

Food was okay. Had a stuffed chicken breast which had no flavor even with the cream sauce. The veggies were also bland. A little disappointing.Staff was very pleasant and personable.

The wait staff is very friendly and creates a cozy atmosphere. The food is delicious and the portions are generous.

I had a wonderful experience at this restaurant. The food was fantastic, the portions were generous, and the staff was friendly. The prices were quite reasonable as well. I discovered this gem after returning on the 5 PM ferry from Connecticut, and I’m so glad I did. I’ll definitely be making this a regular stop on the North Fork.

I've lived just down the block for four years, and I can always rely on O'Mally's, no matter the season. The staff is consistently friendly, and they serve one of the best hamburgers I've ever tasted.