Dutch Valley - Sugarcreek

The positives included the broasted chicken, which I preferred over the pan-fried option. The meatballs were decent, though a bit on the sweet side, and the pickled eggs were fine. The mashed potatoes were passable, and the bread pudding was decent as well, though it could have been warmer. Unfortunately, the negatives far outweighed the positives. The roast beef was flavorless, leaving me regretting my choice to add it to my plate. The rolls tasted like something you’d buy at the store, although my wife enjoyed them. The noodles were overly salty and reminiscent of overcooked instant ramen. The gravy, stuffing, and many other items were lacking in quality. Did I mention how nice and friendly the staff were? If you’re someone who enjoys buffets and is just looking to fill up, this place might work for you. However, personally, I won’t be returning.

**Service:** Dine-in **Meal Type:** Dinner **Price per Person:** $10–20 **Food Rating:** 2 **Service Rating:** 4 **Atmosphere Rating:** 4

**Title: A Wonderful Amish Dining Experience** I recently dined at this fantastic Amish restaurant and couldn't be more pleased. The service was exceptional, making us feel right at home. We enjoyed a delightful dinner, and I found the prices to be quite reasonable, averaging around $20 to $30 per person. Now, onto the food—it was absolutely perfect, deserving a perfect score of 5. The attentive service also earns a solid 5 out of 5. Lastly, the atmosphere was charming and inviting, which also receives a 5. Overall, a wonderful experience that I highly recommend!

Went for breakfast because the restaurant had gotten a good rating. I was disappointed. My wife got the buffet her eggs were brown from being overcooked and her breakfast potatoes had little to no taste. I had pancakes,and they were both doughy/sticky in the middle and barely warm to boot. Parking: Parking is right out front of the building really good sized lot, plenty of spots to accommodate a full restaurant. Service: Dine in

Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Dessert, Noodles, Mashed Potatoes, Gravy, Amish