Gray's Ice Cream - Tiverton

As other reviewers have pointed out, the ingredient list is dominated by various types of gum. Guar, xanthan—this is basically a cream made from gum. Does your cream taste excessively gummy? That's because it’s almost entirely made of gum. If you’re looking to up your gum consumption, this is definitely the place to indulge.

If you enjoy having your ice cream cone handled by disinterested teenagers who don’t wear gloves, then this is the spot for you. Get ready for a Walmart-quality cone experience. What a disappointment compared to Grays. As a local, I found this place to be a letdown. I’ll give it two stars for nostalgia, but otherwise… it deserves none.

As for the ice cream, it was smooth and flavorful, but I couldn’t find anything that made it stand out. In a blind taste test against convenience store samples, I doubt I would have been able to identify it as homemade. Nonetheless, I didn't feel the need to throw it away, so it's worth giving it a try.

We tried their ice cream and was severely disappointed. Tried pistachio and cherry vanilla, both had terrible aftertaste to them and were not very flavorful.

Amazing ice cream! It hasn't changed a bit over the years!