Attilio's Of Tom's River - Toms River

I had a frustrating experience at this restaurant. When I requested different sauces for my garlic knots, the owner told me it was too late because my driver had already left. However, I could see on the app that my driver was still there! This kind of dishonesty is concerning and doesn't reflect well on the business. I would not recommend this place.

The pizza was fantastic and it's one of our favorites. My only complaint is that the amount of corn nuggets you receive for $9 is good, but at this price, we probably won't order it again.

I've been meaning to write a review for a while now. We typically order from Attilio about once a week, and I can confidently say it’s the best place we've tried in Toms River. We've had pizza, wraps, and subs, and everything has been fantastic. Some of our favorite items include the meatball parmesan, chicken Caesar pizza, baked ziti pizza, and the chicken sluice (where you can build your own). We usually place our orders online, which is super convenient (just make sure to order directly from Attilio's). I also want to add a quick note of gratitude for their incredible service when we needed a catering order on short notice. Everyone loved the food—it was absolutely delicious!

Never try this place, but all bad reviews here are really pathetic. This will be my new pizza spot at home as I'm right across. The good reviews make the bad reviews. I worked for 20 years in a pizza shop to check out. I can't wait to try this place, call it my home

Chicken California?without the chicken?.got their garlic knot meatball sliders too thank god. not worth calling to complain. Just won?t order again. 21 dollars plus tip. Looking forward to the next shop in there.