Tastie Cream Incorporated - VESTAL

Finest ice cream in NY PA area. Many flavors and styles.... very clean and well maintained store.

The best Custard I had! Beautiful place to connect with friends. Friendly efficient staff.

Clean shop. Folding tables made of plastic. Friendly and helpful staff. Frozen Custard had some ice on what was not surprising as they don't seem too busy. Pretty expensive. Italian ice cream and soft serving were great and somewhat cheaper.

Always good custard with many flavors, it's worth the price since it has top quality ingredients. We're an hour away but when we are in the area, we always stop. Hope to see it open again soon for another season. Everyone should try it!

Tastie Cream has good ice cream and usually no line. I can only speak to the chocolate soft serve and it is quite delicious. The flavor is not too strong or to weak and the ice cream itself is heavy and creamy when compared to other locations where the ice cream is more course and lighter. They also fill the cone which is a plus unlike some places that serve the cone empty with the ice cream on top. I always order a small and my son orders a medium. The cones do end up being noticeably different in size. I cannot say that for the place a few miles west down the road where a medium and small are often the same. My only issue is this place is about $2 more expensive per cone than other locations nearby. I suppose it balances out though when you factor in the heavier and better quality ice cream than the other places I have tried.