Pizza Guys - Village of Lancaster

A few months back I stopped in to get a few slices of pizza after working all day roughly 30 minutes before they closed. They told me that they all ready cleaned everything and that they wouldn't make any more pizza for the night. Maybe change your business hours if you aren't going to actually make and serve pizza during that time. Just close earlier. Won't be stopping here any time soon.

After a long, hard day of work on a Saturday, I stopped by to pick up a couple of slices. I thought I'd give it a try try pizza look like it had been sitting there all day still against my better judgment. I ordered one's slice (I wanted two). I could tell by his face that he knew it'd been sitting there all day brought the pizza to the back to what I'm assuming was to warm it up. I've tasted better frozen pizza. I don't like leaving bad Google reviews, but to the pizza company in question, if you are reading this, do your customers a service and don't serve them cardboard pizza.

$9 for a 2 cups of lettuce salad. Skip. The Margarita pizza is a cheese pizza. The pizza was decent, but don't bother with a salad or sides. The fries have no seasoning and the onion rings leave something to be desired. The salads are aggressively overpriced. I couldn't fill a soup bowl..... and the ingredients are lettuce and dressing. The markup is insane. That $0.90 worth of ingredients. Cool.

We tried Pizza Guys through Slice ordering and got a cheese and pepperoni pizza, stuffed shells, medium wings and garlic knots. Everything was delicious. The stuffed shells were out of this world. So so much cheese on top which I loved. My fiance loved the medium wings which were crispy and saucy too. The garlic knots were great in addition to the pizza. The pizza does not have the typical cup pepperoni but it's a good change of pace with a thinner crust. We will be back! Ordering on slice was awesome too. Lower prices than doordash and other food delivery apps usually have. Great value.

Wanted to like the pizza since location is so convenient so many pizza choices. BUT, crust is not good. I like a thin crust, but this was like cardboard..no taste whatsoever, like a frozen pizza. So disappointing. Want to give a second chance, maybe try a sub or wings. But will not do another pizza unless dough recipe improves.