1839 Restaurant And Bar

What a pleasant experience! We always make it a point to visit Brotherhood Winery, and being it is only 20miles from us, I wish we visited more. A later Saturday afternoon to do a tasting, buy a case or two and some dinner. I love the venue, as it isrelaxing, and can be as fancy or as laid back as you want. Very attentive staff, great cocktails and a nice wineselection. The appetizers, and entrees had a phenomenal flavor profile, well prepared, generous portions and overall a verysatisfying meal. We will be back and next time to sample the brunch menu. If you are visiting the area, special trip for theShawangunk Wine Trail for the Holidays which is fun by the way) be sure to stop at 1839 for some great food!

Poutine fries were delicious! We waited a while for entrees and service was a bit slow but food was tasty.

Excellent food and service. Everyone was pleased with their meal. The brisket app, osso bucco main, and floorless chocolate cake were standouts off of the restaurant week price fix menu. My only complaint is that the Friday special price fix menu is not on the website-just that it exists and the price, not the items. Also, the entrance is a bit difficult to find. A road circles the grounds. You have to park and walk into the circle to enter the buildings and restaurants.

The winery is great- the restaurant was ok- my husband had a $18 mediocre burger that didn't come with the coleslaw it was supposed to. I got the skillet bread which wasn't edible- it was completely black- whoever let it leave the kitchen should be ashamed.

Amazing food and service! we're getting married here next year and we are very happy with the food, ambiance and helpful staff.