Joe Cristiano's Pizza

Been eating out a lot, using door dash instead of getting my lazy buns out of the office, so we've been trying all sorts of places. Oh. My. Gosh. This was some of the best food I've shoved down my fat throat in a long time! Tasty boneless wings, soooo much toppings on the pizza, and even my picky a child loved the cheesy bread. I think this will be our new regular place to order from! Fantastic! No pictures because we shoveled it down so fast.

I ordered from this restaurant on Valentine's Day and wanted to share my experience. My wife requested heart-shaped pizzas over the phone earlier in the day and was told to specify it in the comments of our online order. When the pizzas arrived, she was visibly upset and called to express her dissatisfaction. The restaurant not only replaced the pizzas with perfect heart-shaped ones, but also gave us a bonus pizza dough heart filled with cheese as an apology. Excellent service.

This is the best place for delicious pizza slices and the friendliest staff in town.

The dough was disappointing, lacking flavor and resembling cardboard. The vegetable pizza had very few toppings, with small, unrecognizable vegetables and tasteless black olives. Overall, a disappointing experience.

I ordered a pizza for pick-up through DoorDash. I arrived at 7:52 PM, just before they closed at 8 PM. However, when I got there, the front doors were locked and despite knocking and calling, no one came to the door. I have been a customer of this restaurant for years, both at the Hyde Park and Wappingers locations, because they have the best pizza. However, they need to ensure they have employees who close up correctly and on time. I did not receive the food I ordered and did not even get a refund, as they claimed I picked up my order at 8:38 PM, when they close at 8.