Gaetanos - Willoughby Hills

I have never had a chicken parm sandwich better than the one at this restaurant! This is definitely one of, if not the best Italian restaurants I have ever dined at. I highly recommend it!

Went here for pizza after a really long weekend. Always drove by but never tried. Ordered a Large 8-cut pizza with alfredo and pepperoni, and a Large 8-cut pizza with sausage and mushroom. It was good. The Alfredo is creamy and delicious, and they put a little more on which I loved. The appeared to use a thick cut pepperoni as well, meaty and full of goodness. The mushrooms were fresh and I enjoy the asteroid sausage, which they serve, rather than the crumbled, sliced, or proceed sausage. OK 3 stars. Service was great. The sauce was great. Fresh ingredients great. Sausage was mild and slightly bland. The dough is where it needed some help. I noticed the bottom was cooked well, but it was a bit doughy. I love cold left over pizza (I know I'm odd). Even the next day, the pizza was a bit doughy. Maybe a little more bake time? idk. I'd try it again.

Karen was very friendly and informative. Will come again.

I tried Gaetano's for the first time and ordered two large pizzas. The ingredients were fresh and the crusts were thin, just how we like them. The pizza was very good, but it's worth noting that their large size is only 12 inches, which is closer to a medium size at other places.

First time patrons. Food and service was terrific at a very reasonable price. We will be back and recommend to others.