Borgata Pizza Cafe - Worthington

The pizza arrived hot and was very delicious. The delivery driver was friendly and pleasant.

Overall, the meal was just alright. The gnocchi was excessively drenched in pesto—really, there was so much pesto that it masked the other vegetable flavors (I ordered it made Tuscan style). While it tasted decent, the strong pesto flavor overshadowed everything else. The garlic bread with cheese on the side had a comically small amount of cheese. The photo advertised a slice loaded with cheese, but that wasn't the case. On a bright note, the chocolate chip cannoli was absolutely fantastic!

The pizza here is fantastic! The Supreme Pizza is so delicious that it brings back memories of my trips to New Haven, CT. If you have the chance to dine in, I highly recommend it. However, I have to say they haven't quite figured out the takeout situation. I've often found that items are missing, orders have mistakes, or my delivery driver ends up waiting around for a long time. Overall, I'd rate the pizza a solid 5 stars, but the delivery deserves only about 2 stars. Nevertheless, the issues haven’t stopped me from ordering repeatedly!

Borgata is our go-to spot for delicious pizza and pasta! The atmosphere is lively and quite open, so keep that in mind before your visit. We absolutely love it here; the staff and the food are exceptional. Be sure to try the pasta and stuffed peppers—they offer more than just great pizza! Overall, we rate the food a perfect 5, service a 5, and the atmosphere a 4.

Good New York style pizza. Hot Italian sausage stuffed peppers are really good and definitely spicy. Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Spicy Sausage Stuffed Peppers, Cheese NY Style Pizza