County Line Pizza - Zanesville

After the place was sold, the pizza wasn't any good. New owners changed the sauce and crust, taste like cardboard. The subs are awful! We stopped ordering from there. We miss the old owners and their pizza recipes. Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner

Y'all this is the best pizza I have had in Indiana. Just a quick background on my love for pizza. I grew up in New Haven CT and anyone who know anything about pizza knows New Haven CT has the best pizza. Well I have lived in Indiana since 2011 and have not found pizza worth buying a second time until now. Not just a second time will we be buying but we have ordered more to bring home tonight. The pizza is not just tasty but cut correctly into triangles not squares. The crust is cook to a perfect crisp making the dough having the right chewyness to it, the sauce is very nice not sweet at all which as a New Havener it means a lot. There is literally the perfect amount of cheese as well. We got pepperoni and bacon for topping and there was just the right amount of both on the pie not over doing it. We also ordered their garlic cheese bread which was friggin awesome! And I had a side salad..not my preferred blend of lettuce but it was a good portion and well put together. Our waitresses name was Tiffany and she was very sweet and attentive. Dan the owner came over and greeted us and was very informative as well as answered all my nosie questions without hesitation. I 100% recommend if you are anywhere near Zanesville Indiana y'all come check them out.

The best pizza I have had in Indiana and it’s a small mom and pop place They make you feel like you’re family even it being our first time eating there great people owner Dan was very friendly and Tiffany the bartender/waitress was on top of everything It was a great experience and will be going back many many more times Thanks for finally bringing great pizza to Indiana

Best pizza in town Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

The price is way too high for what you receive. Additionally, they don't serve subs, even though they're listed on the menu. I won’t be returning. **Service:** Dine-in **Meal type:** Dinner **Price per person:** $50–100 **Food rating:** 1/5 **Service rating:** 4/5 **Atmosphere rating:** 4/5 **Recommended dish:** Garlic Cheese Bread **Parking:** Plenty of parking available **Parking options:** Free parking lot