Pauls Live From New York Pizza Arcata

Always an exceptional experience! They were out of sausage rolls, but they made one for me from scratch in just about 7 minutes. Amazing!!!

Fantastic pizza! My son tried the double-crust spinach pie and thought it would be perfect with some black olives, though he still really enjoyed it. I had a salad with chicken that was beautifully prepared, featuring fresh local greens and generously topped with seasoned chicken, making it an excellent gluten-free choice.

Delicious! Adding pineapple to my godfather slice is a great choice—so tasty!

Authentic Italian Flavors at Paul’s Live From New York Pizza in Arcata, CA I went to Paul’s Live From New York Pizza in Arcata, Ca a few years ago. I was treated to an unexpected delight in the form of the best cannoli I’ve ever had. It wasn’t just the pizza that impressed; their cannoli took the experience to a whole new level of Italian culinary excellence. From the first bite, the pizza showcased classic New York style with a perfect crust, robust sauce, and generously topped with quality ingredients. Each slice was a testament to authentic flavors and meticulous preparation. However, the highlight of my visit was undoubtedly the cannoli. It was impeccably crafted with a crispy shell and a lusciously creamy filling, striking a fine balance of sweetness and texture that made each bite memorable. Paul’s Live From New York Pizza serves up the best cannoli that I have ever tasted! : This spot is a must-visit for anyone in Arcata looking for a taste of genuine Italian fare. The delightful combination of great pizza and the best cannoli makes it a culinary gem worth exploring.

We ordered for pick up on our way to our campsite. Husband has the Hawaii 5-0 as he lives his pineapple and ham pizzas. I had the Pesto Paradise substitute sausage for pepperoni. Excellent! We talked about driving the hour back to get another before we leave the area.