Cutthroat Cafe - Bailey

I stopped by with my family after searching for a Christmas tree, and we had a wonderful experience. Our waitress, Jess, was fantastic—so friendly and charming! The food was delicious, and the cook was very personable, coming out to chat with us before he left. It truly felt like we were being treated as family friends.

Upon entering, you’re immediately enveloped in a warm, welcoming atmosphere that feels just like home, and you're greeted with friendly smiles! The owner, Chip, is incredibly kind and makes it a point to visit each table to ensure you're enjoying your dining experience. It’s a place where you truly feel like part of the family. The food is comforting and reminiscent of home-cooked meals, absolutely delicious! In our opinion, the standout dish is the 'Long Horn Burger'—topped with green chili, onions, and cheese, it’s a substantial and satisfying meal!

I've already enjoyed their burgers, which were great, but the chopped Sirloin Steak is truly the most unique and beautifully prepared steak I've ever experienced. It melts in your mouth as if it were ground beef. It's such a delightful steak that I can only imagine how amazing it would be if they served it with rolls on the side. Cutthroat Café? More like Cutthroat Steakhouse! Everyone needs to try the chopped Sirloin Steak!

Great cafe. You do it right, great prices, good portion and SUPER FRIENDLY employees. A few months ago moved to Bailey, did not know that they were open for dinner, glad that we decided to stop and see. Come back!

Stopped in after our home inspection in the area : . This place has true home cookin! In fact, I was told that all their recipes are lovingly handed down from the owner’s mom! Roast beef, mashed potatoes and gravy was delicious. From scratch noodles in the chicken soup too! Awesome service. Friendly diner that feels like stepping back in time, where the food and the people are truly real.... definitely a gem. Can’t wait to try their breakfast next time.