Schiano's Pizza - BAYVILLE

I also ordered a chicken bacon ranch pizza, which featured a perfectly crispy crust. The bacon was just right—crispy without being overcooked. The combination of the chicken and ranch tied the entire pizza together beautifully. The wings we had were cooked to perfection; they were crispy and came with sauce on the side, which made it convenient for the kids to enjoy plain wings while we savored the sweet chili sauce. We also tried the garlic knots, which are often hit or miss, but these were fantastic—delightfully fluffy on the inside and crispy on the outside. Overall, my family and I have discovered another amazing place for takeout. The cherry on top was that we placed our order last minute at 5:45 PM, expecting delivery at 7 PM, but our food arrived at 6:20 PM. I highly recommend trying this place out; the food is excellent!

I recently relocated to the area and was on the hunt for truly excellent local and authentic pizza. I came across a Facebook review of Schiano's and decided to bring some fellow food enthusiasts along for a late lunch. The calamari appetizer was fresh and cooked to perfection. We ordered a pizza half-topped with meatballs, onions, and mushrooms, and the other half with sausage, and it was absolutely amazing! The restaurant offers a great dinner menu for guests looking to sample a variety of dishes. Thanks to Brendan and Annamaria, we felt incredibly welcomed. You don't stay in business for over 50 years without being outstanding!

The food was absolutely delicious, and the staff were incredibly friendly and professional. In today’s world, such genuine qualities can be hard to find. I highly recommend this hidden gem!

Good pizza, friendly staff, seating so that the family can enjoy time together. Food is always fresh. Can't wait to go back and try some of their desserts

I deliver food service products to this establishment weekly. Every single time I am there, the entire staff, from ownership to every employee, and I mean EVERY employee, are some of the nicest, sincerest and real people I have ever had the pleasure of interacting with. I have eaten here as well and the food portions are huge. There is no skimping on toppings for pizzas and it is delicious here. Please please please, do yourself a favor and dine here, you WILL NOT be disappointed