Anthony's Pizza - Berwyn

I called the restaurant to inquire about the discrepancy and spoke with a woman who informed me that the driver had written $5 on the tip line. I insisted that I only tipped $3 and was certain about it. The woman confirmed that my tip was indeed $3 and took down my information to have the owner call me. Unfortunately, the owner never reached out. I decided to dispute the charge with my bank, and they promptly refunded my money. I advise potential customers to be cautious and remember to ask for a copy of the receipt. After this experience, I will not be ordering from here again. Additionally, I found the pizza to be bland and not as tasty as I remembered from my last visit back in 2020.

This is the best pizza in town—I've tried all the options! Their quality and prices (especially with coupons) can't be matched. When you order pizza 20 times, you earn a free one; we've managed to get 5 free pizzas over the course of 15 years. My only wish is that they could update their dining area a bit.

Got the 35.99 coupon in the wing for wings and a large pizza so decided to give Anthony?s a shot. The pizza was flavorless, the wings were not good quality and the ranch (or blue cheese) looked green and watered down. The ranch was also spilled on the sideof the wings upon delivery. Absolutely will not be ordering from here again

If I could give zero stars, I would. I ordered the family deal, and the pizza was incredibly hard while the chicken was inedible. The chicken smelled and tasted like it was soaked in burnt oil. Unfortunately, this wasn’t the first time I’ve had a bad experience. We ended up throwing the chicken away because nobody could eat it—not even the dog wanted it!

This place is a hood institution for a reason, jumbo slice and a can of pop for $4.50. You CANNOT beat that. No frills hole in the wall with a great deal on pizza by the slice. It?s not fancy, but this is Cicero, so what do you expect? Love it.