Hamilton's - Brooklyn

I used to live nearby and visited this restaurant at least ten times. While their menu isn't extensive, the items they do offer...

The food is decent, but the service is quite poor. I've had several lackluster experiences over the years, but today was the worst, and I’ve decided to stop trying.

I visited this restaurant with friends after completing a half-marathon, and we had a wonderful experience. We were promptly seated in a beautifully decorated outdoor area. We decided to share a flight...

I would rate this restaurant zero stars if I could. The food was inedible. Who wants horseradish-flavored eggs? That’s what you end up with when they throw a literal salad on top of them. What genius decided that a salad belongs with breakfast? Their "homestyle country gravy with sausage" was essentially just a roux with pork added, which is why it had an orange tint. It was unappetizing. The eggs were repulsive. And as for the "fresh juice"... it was just a small can of pineapple juice, which they charge $4 for! DO NOT EAT HERE. They must be paying for reviews because there’s no way this place deserves a 4/5 star rating. It’s simply disgusting.

My husband, son, dog and I shared a lovely outdoor table. Our server, Katie, was sweet and efficient. The food was underwhelming at best. We shared a large mussels, which were overcooked and in an under-reduced broth. And served with a teaspoon! We also had a very, very greasy Reuben with excellent potato wedges. My son had a cod and shrimp cake which was just plain terrible. We're going to give it another shot because it was a pleasant experience but the food was definitely disappointing.