Italiano's Pizza - CAPE MAY

Avoid this place. Ordered cheese slices and white slice and French fries. French fries and white slice were very good. Regular cheese was horrible. Sauce was off and cheese tasted weird. I love pizza and would never pass up a slice. I took one bite and refused the rest. Saw one customer get served burnt slices. Also no sign for cash only until after you ordered

Not only is the pizza awful, there were groups of kids hanging in the doorway and at the tables, and they were rude. The clerk didn't say a word to them (we are still in Covid) no masks, and no social distancing. We passed one other time to go to the restaurant next door, and there were a ton of kids on bikes hanging in the doorway. The pizza was disgusting. It wasn't hot, the slice was huge, and it was all dough, with no taste. Will not be going back.

This pizzeria is a small, traditional spot run by one man. It is welcoming and located right by the water. It is one of the few places open during the offseason and open after 3pm. The delicious smell drew us in, and we were pleasantly surprised to receive free garlic knots as soon as we arrived. The option to dine outdoors or indoors was nice. The owner seems very eager to feed his customers, giving off a nostalgic vibe reminiscent of old school places in Connecticut or New York City. This is definitely a must-visit for anyone looking for great pizza, as one slice is enough for a satisfying meal.

Terrible prices and terrible eating. no list of prices, it was sketched and far too expensive. probably some of the worst pizza I had, tasted better.

The pizza we had at this restaurant was dry, tasteless, and seemed like it had been sitting out all day. We purchased three slices for $15.00 at 9:00 a.m. and were very disappointed. We will not be returning. Unfortunately, Louie's has lost a loyal customer.