The Way Home - Carbondale

I had a wonderful time relaxing on the dog-friendly outdoor patio while enjoying live music on a Friday. We enjoyed it so much that we returned the next morning for brunch. The atmosphere and service were both excellent, and there was plenty of outdoor seating available. The interior decor was lovely as well. I tried a delicious cocktail, and the brunch was fantastic too.

Everything on the menu is absolutely incredible. It offers a delightful culinary experience for those who truly appreciate good food. The menu changes with the seasons and features local meats and produce. While the prices are on the higher side and the portions are small, we usually save this place for special occasions when we want to indulge in great quality. For two people, we recommend ordering one dish from each course to share! The patios are lovely on summer evenings, and the bar is great as well.

Next up was the pasta, which arrived on an incredibly small plate—I've seen larger serving dishes! For $12, I received a portion that felt more like it belonged in a teacup. While the house-made pasta was good, the overcooked broccoli completely overshadowed the dish. We then ordered the smoked trout, but we almost changed our minds due to the long wait for it to arrive. When it finally did come, it was surprisingly small for something listed in the “large plate” section of the menu—I could have eaten it in a single bite. Although the $38 fish was tasty, it simply wasn’t worth the price. I wish I could say that my experience was an exaggeration, but unfortunately, we left feeling both hungry and disappointed. While there were some enjoyable elements, there were too many letdowns for me to give more than a one-star review. I’d like to give this place another chance, but... well, you can figure out the rest.

I actually didn't get to stay at The Way Home, but I want to write a review to express my gratitude for the flexibility and kindness that Jess showed me when I almost stayed there. She offered to pick me up from the airport when I realized my rental car plan was no longer an option.My flight was then delayed a day, so I asked Jess if they could refund some of my reservation (which was at peak time during X-Games). She was very understanding and helpful and refunded me part of the charge. Thank you!

There are pluses such as friendly staff. The poutine is very good! Seating is not very comfortable, booth style or chairs with bouncy backs that offer no support. Pasta dish was oversalted. Has potential. Will try again. Prices on the higher end. Dinner menu has Aspen prices, higher than expected for this location.