Menemsha Fish Market - CHILMARK

My wife and I both had the lobster bisque. It was amazing, very delicious, very filling Don't miss this place because there's a whole lot more to love. Lots of live lobsters and great fish. This is a wonderful restaurant.

Honestly, a little disappointed. The food is fresh, but if you plan to order a cold lobster roll, they are pre made and you get it yourself out of the fridge? We wanted something made to order so we ordered the hot butter lobster roll, almost seems like those are premade also and just put, bun and all, in the microwave. The bun was so soggy it was mush right when we unwrapped it, inedible. We are asked for a fresh roll and transferred the lobster meat into the new roll. To the raw bar side, ordered a dozen oysters, this isn’t anything that larsens did but I just feel like it should be said how large these oyster were, I’m talking filled your mouth and had to chew for a while huge. We also ended up not eating most of them. I remember coming here years ago and it was a really great experience. The past 2 years I just feel like they could do better.

I have a lot of mixed feelings about this place. On the one hand, you have fresh seafood because that is their specialty. On the other, you have a place that overcharges and I even saw a microwave being used to prepare certain foods. I decided to get crab cakes, the stuffed quahog, and the lobster Mac and cheese (this all came to close to $30). Upon reading my order you 'd probably say yea, that checks out but you 'd be wrong. The lobster Mac and cheese, which was clearly the most expensive at $14, came served on a small around 4-6inch paper plate...made with rigatoni noodles. You could maybe fit 15 noodles on the plate with a few pieces of lobster. Overall I am disappointed because I didn 't hate it but I shouldn 't spend close to $30 and still be hungry afterwards.

Located in Menemsha Bay on the Vineyard, Larsens fish market speaks for itself. For fresh local seafood this is the place. Why were we here? One word, OYSTAHs (oysters) lol. All fresh seafood is at Market price or they have special for oysters, usually dozen for $30. We had half dozen of Katana Bays and Menemsha Spearpoint oysters, both were great but I did prefer Spearpoint. They were so good we decided to order another dozen, this time just Spearpoint. Wife was REALLY HAPPY .

Small hole in the wall. got fried muscheln (off menu,) hot lobster roll cold lobster roll and two fresh oysters, which she fed right in front of me. great to go eat too- picked fish pate, lobster bisque and clam chowder for christmas day. the staff was super sweet! on a bank outside on the water ate