Paesano's Pizzeria - City of New York

Came here for authentic NY pizza after the 5 Boro Bike Tour and was not disappointed!! SO GOOD! Thank you for your hospitality Jimmy and the rest of the gang!Food: 5/5

My review is purely based on take out of a cheese pizza. Food 2/5 The pizza we ordered honestly was not the best. It could've just been my pizza pie, but when we started eating it, it was cold (not the fault of the pizzeria as we had to drive back home) and a bit dry hard. My biggest disappointment in the pizza was the taste. I honestly felt like it taste a bit cardboard like. The dough was too tough and the crust was definitely thin. You can tell from the photos. Service 5/5 Great lady working behind the counter. I could tell they had a passion for what they did. They treat their customers with respect. The sweetest lady I've ever met. Ambiance 5/5 Regular pizza take our spot with a fantastic lady behind the counter. My only suggestion for the pizzeria is to improve the ratio of cheese and sauce. That may add to the taste as the pizza felt like I was eating cardboard. 3/5 great ambiance and service, pizza not too great.

I got the shrimp salad which was great although the shrimp was slightly burned. My husband had the chicken salad, which he liked. We got a sausage and parm sandwich for my husband's uncle and he loved it. It would have been nice if utensils were packed for us as we did not realize this until later but overall good place.

I was first recommended by my fellow friend and work partner, Wallace Chen. He recommended that I get a pizza from this fine establishment on a Monday evening. I have to say that i was pleasantly suprised with the quality of the pizza. I rate the crust 8.3/10, the cheese a 7.1/10 and the sauce was impeccable with a score of 9.8/10 and it reminded me of my tour in italy when i went to naples. I have to say, besides the cheese making me a little gassy afterwards, it was a great tasting pie and i reccomend you visit and order from this pizzeria.

For all the folks that have given this a 5 star rating I totally get it. The food is actually good. But have you ever walked into this place? To say it’s filthy is an understatement. The floors , walls, door handles , phones, I mean everything is absolutely greasy and dirty. They store dirty shoes in the seating area I have no idea how they got any eating at all from NYC. You don’t need to be a rocket scientist to figure out that the kitchen is kept the same way. And I agree with the other reviews , the guy behind the counter is unpleasant. Doesn’t even answer when you say hi.