Buckeye Slice - Columbus

Definitely the best legitimate New York style pizza place in town. Locally owned and operated, Buckeye Slice is my favorite to get a real taste of New York, and honestly is the best pizza in town. Fresh, crisp out of the oven taste, you owe it to yourself if you haven't tried it!

Great little pizza shop! Great NY style pie, great crust! Was the former 'Flying Pizza ' shop, same recipe! Young man that owns is very nice and is working hard to build the business (was an employee of the former owner). I was referred by a co-worker, and tried it out with my family. They LOVE IT ! Kids are always asking to go back...I guess we will...tonight!

This is my favorite pizza in Columbus. It's a hidden gem. The crust is thin and has some crunch and the right amount of chew. The sauce is not too sweet, not too tangy. There is just the right amount of cheese. Stop in for a slice and you won't regret it.

I've been coming here for years and appreciate the consistency of the delicious New York-style pizza they serve. Seeing as I grew up in New York and I'm frequently there on business. I can tell you it's the real deal. Check it out, you will be pleased.

Has 3 booths and some high chairs along the wall to sit at. We're always on lookout for pizza places to eat at. Refills on drinks. Friendly staff. Locally owned and operated. Enjoyed the giant slice of cheese pizza!!