Matero's Pub Pizza - Custer

The best pizza I have had in a long time! The sauce and flavor were amazing. The service was fast and the staff were very friendly. I will definitely be returning. Thank you, Cousin Marc Stalter, for recommending this place on your Facebook.

The restaurant consistently serves incredible food and drinks, and the hospitality is always exceptional. I love it!

Excellent Shrimp Pizza and cheese curds. Staff was very friendly and helpful

Johnny is the best bartender we have ever had. Great drinks and fantastic sense of humor! Food was great!

I have visited this restaurant three times now. The first time was for the Friday fish fry, the food was excellent but the service was average. The second time I had spaghetti which was good but nothing extraordinary, the service was nice. On our third visit, we ordered a meat pizza that was a special on the menu. Unfortunately, the bartender brought out the wrong pizza and when we informed him, he gave us the option to wait for the correct one or eat the wrong one. We decided to eat it since we were hungry. Our waitress then came out and admitted she entered the order incorrectly but offered to correct it. Despite our refusal, she put in the correct order and also added an order of cheese curds for us. Moments later, she returned and informed us that the boss instructed her to take back the wrong pizza, even though we had already eaten five slices of it. We did receive the cheese curds for free, even though we had not ordered them. Although the food is good, the experience has made us hesitant to return to this restaurant.