Blue Sky Bagels - Garden City

Employees there were super nice on my visit yesterday (7/11/23) but got my order wrong and I didn’t realize it was wrong until I had made it to work. They gave me an onion bagel when I asked for wheat for my breakfast sandwich and then gave me hardly any cream cheese on my Asiago bagel that also had a hair in it… usually this place is great I essentially didn’t get what I paid for.

Visit any other location, but pass on this one. The manager is so passive aggressive and rude and her staff seem great but she doesn't let them do their jobs and she makes comments about the people ordering specifically so we can hear her. Happened to me and the two ladies in front of me in line. Sheesh.Food: 2/5

Got a turkey sandwich on asiago n cheese bagel and it was delish!! definitely will be back to try more. We also bought a bakers dozen to go! yum...

Just had my first bagel ever from there and I won't go back. I got a parmesan bagel that literally had no taste at all. I also got it with the garden veggie cream cheese that had no veggies or herbs in it except for big chunks of tomatoes. Just call it tomato chunk cream cheese. Sarah's bagel is a tad more expensive, but the taste and quality is clearly better.

Poor and disingenuous service. When asked if they had caffeine free tea, the response was no. I thought they may have some so I rephrased it into an herbal tea, that 's caffeine free and asked if she knew that. The manager responded , we are not baristas . I said it 's fairly common knowledge and that she learned something today. Her energy and attitude was fake and condescending and ingratiating. In addition, I asked for a toasted bagel with tuna. Was cold and tuna was overly dry and all this for 11 bucks. Not sure why she didn 't just say, oh, I didn 't know that. She was ready to let me leave without knowing that her teas were not that sophisticated. Although she was and there 's nothing more annoying than an introverted empath picking up on inauthenticity and apathy. What a terrible experience. She should be working in a locked office in the dungeon where she doesn 't have to engage anyone but Spot from the Munsters!