The Cellar - Geneseo

My family and I enjoyed one of the BEST tasting steaks ever! My NY Strip was cooked to perfection, bake potato and side of veggies were perfect and my house salad with their in-house green dressing was very good. We topped our dinner off with a verytasty carrot cake. Our server was very professional and did an outstanding job! I will definitely return if I'm ever in the areaagain. This is the place to go if you are looking for a great tasting steak for a reasonable price.

Had a private party of 30 people. Made us order from limited menu, didn't let us order appetizers. Some tables didn't get enough rolls for everyone seated, when asking forore were told no. Many steaks weren't cooked correctly, when asked to fixacted like it was a big deal. Waitress said she wished we had gone somewhere else to eat. Absolutely the worst service of mylife. Will never be back. Over priced and terrible service.

I have been here quite a few times and every time the food is fantastic. And reasonably priced as well. The salads are the best I've had. The garlic and Greek goddess dressings are great. Service is outstanding. I didn't give it 5 because it in a basement with no windows and no TVs. Also an older crowd.

We love the Cellar for its steaks, ribs and homemade salad dressings but lately we have been a bit disappointed with the service ... they seem to be very rushed while serving you and makes it a less than ideal dining experience especially for the high end price you pay for the food. They also don 't offer the wonderful dressing carousel that they used to and are very stingy with the dressing that they give you these days :

The food was delicious, the atmosphere and ambiance was nice, the service excellent. If you enjoy fine dining, this is the place to go!