Caddy Shack - Kelleys Island

I always have a wonderful experience here! The bartenders are absolutely the prettiest on the island! The kitchen staff could use a little more friendliness, but honestly, if I had to work next to a hot pizza oven on sweltering summer nights, I might be a bit grumpy too! The subs are amazing, and their grilled wings rank among the best I've ever tasted! However, the restrooms leave much to be desired—they're almost as hot as the kitchen! Overall, all the public restrooms on the island are quite rough. This place should definitely be on your list when visiting AI! I've created great memories here for the past 20 years! I do hope The Caddy Shack can collaborate with The Casino in the future.

We've been visiting Kelleys Island for years, but this was our first time at this new spot. The bartender and staff were wonderful; they encouraged us to return to try their incredible wings, and they truly lived up to the hype. The pizza was also fantastic. Overall, great staff, excellent prices, and delicious food!

The Caddy Shack is a must-visit for me every time I come to the island. The food is fantastic, and the service is even better! I highly recommend the pizzas, sandwiches, and Brett's wings—they're the best I've ever had.

Love the staff in Caddy, and the Italian sub is the best, no one should leave the island without the Caddy Shack experience

The food and staff are great! The entertainment is an added bonus. Love this place! It simply rocks!