Garden Deli Pizzeria - Manteo

I've been wanting to try this restaurant for a while since I always see it when I'm getting a Big Mac across the street. I decided to stop by today, but the website is down even though the sign says to order online. I suppose I could call and ask them to read the entire menu to me.

We have ordered from Garden Deli several times and, despite overlooking multiple mistakes due to the presence of several teenagers working there, we will not be ordering from here again. During our last few visits, our food has been poorly assembled, we’ve received the wrong orders, and the food has been cold. I have tried to contact the owner via email but have not received any response. There are much better pizza places around than this one.

Pizza was good, but ordered three pizzas and they only delivered two. Called back and they wrote down wrong order even though they read it back as 3 pizzas when ordering. Owner called back and would not honor their mistake. Will NEVER order there again.

Really good, affordable single slices! Flavor of the pizza, even the cheese, was different and really good. Not super greasy. $3 slices plus .50 cents per topping. Spent about $12 for 4 slices. Take out only right now- call ahead and pick up on the porch.

Avoid this place. The service is painfully slow, and they frequently mess up orders. My pizza was lacking toppings, and I paid for extra meat on my gyro, but what I received were just three paper-thin slices—if that's extra, I can only imagine how little the standard portion must be. They also forgot one order of wings and didn't include the dressing for the wings that were actually delivered. An absolute disaster. 0/10, would not recommend.